Idea - 5, fruits, animals, surreal and real, that is wild spirit!
Technique - 4, girl face and skin is too realistic and I don't like color.

Idea: 3 -The ground idea with someone reaching out in that way is not very original, but that's not cruical here. What's good here is in fact that it's been worked on nicely. Nice flow and pretty good composition.
Technique: 4 - Doing these images with surreal blending with abstract sources are a modern and retro style that's flying around at the moment. It takes a lot to make it very good. This is a good way up there with nice processing both in terms of color and contrast as well as light and texture. Maybe could've worked more with the dynamic of the model. More realism in the face, a stronger expression and more contrast over all in the harmony between foreground vs background.

/rapid

TECHNIQUE: 5 (neither one thing is in wrong place, and everything is making a point IDEA-3 (we can all see that u were not trying as u can!)

TECHNIQUE - 5 (U always buy me with details..)....But there is something about your model I realy don't like (it could be her face expression), mayby she should be in smoke to.. So..IDEA-3

I love it! Idea: well, 5, even though I'm not sure why is it called 'wild spirit'. ...Technique: 5!!! Lots and lots of flawless details! That's all I need:D

Idea 4...technique big 5...girl is from my point of view too realistic and has human touch..although she is in air sorounded by smoke. She should me more ghost-ly and heavenly. Beautiful..and greetings to the author.

I'll start with the technique. Which is 5. Why? Because I'm truly convinced that everything is real.Idea - If this is a girl (meaning young woman) - I see the perfect point of using her as a main object in some kind of struggle with those horses. Girl vs. challenge (wild side of life - horses). So from me - 5.

Idea: 5 Skill / Tehnique: 5

IDEA: 4
TECHNIQUE:5

All I can say is....Amazing...fantastic work...
IDEA:5, as customiZer said "everything is like it should be"
TECHNIQUE:5, "smoke animals" are fabulous...actually I'm not pleased with that grass, but the rest is really breathtaking...

IDEA: 5 (Fantastic, I really can't see anything bad, everything is like it should be, simple but something to think about)
TECHNIQUE: 5 ( Also brilliant, a lot of attention was given to every detail and that "smoke animals" are fascinanting)