Idea - 5, good expression of wild, "not static".
Technique - 4, I think that this is not so good color solution

Idea: 1 - Here I don't understand the idea to go through the theme. I do "understand" it but I don't like the solution since it's a bit to litteral and easy setup, more or less. Technique: 1 - Here there's way to much going on with things around the actual horse here who the focus. I have mainly 2 problems here. 1 is that it looks like they're having sex and 2, the background steals to much attention from the actual work. /rapid

U realy make this horse alive! This is what i call great perception! And u made it: I'm staring at it! Technique: 4 ( but realy! it will be pity if u will not find out the color mounting that u can use in one pic! U are realy great!!! Idea: 5

TEHNIQUE - 3 ( you just overdo it...especially the wall..) IDEA - 3 I really thing that you could have placed "the gost horse" so much better then you did...

Love the idea: 5! Technique:4... just because some parts are neglected and 'too real' compared to the rest of the image.

idea 3, technique 3..i would gave some colagge touch into this performance, specialy with horses..it's ok.

TECHNIQUE: 5 (I think that you did a great job here with making all these horses to be a part of one image, you created a clear image with small mistakes, like straight-white cutout of the horse. You can get a better way of getting out this horse from image - like making curved and distorted paper edge or findig one wilder horse, still 5 because of fine details)
IDEA: 5 (When I first look at the thumbnail image I thought: 'O my God, what is that horse doing to white horse?!?', but I didn't saw what I was affraid of. You fooled me and that is one of the good sides of this wallpaper. And this horse is so wild that he can't be still even in a picture. You missed some things to be even wilder, but thats the part of the technique.)

technique - 4. Idea - 3. To predictable way of solving the "problem" with the theme.

Idea: 5, Technique: 5

IDEA: 5, TECHNIQUE 4 (not 5 just because I don't like purple... very subjective, otherwise it would be 5)

IDEA:3..I don't really like it... What I mean is...you can't feel that spirit which is wanted...I think it would be much better if you made that horse running instead of just standing on his back legs...Actually, I don't really like "picture in picture" wallpapers...
TECHNIQUE:3...I think that colours should be much stronger in this theme, or if you want "wilder"..and that horse shape isn't good enough...I mean, shouldn't you see wall through it, or some kind of move, or something like that...?
Maybe I'm too strict, but that's my seeing of this work...